- Barry Villaverde
Note: If you have not already done so, please go back and read Part One and Part Two of this study.
It is within the context we have previously studied in Matthew 18:1–17 that Jesus continues in verses 18–20.
In the previous parts of this study, we have concentrated on the immediate and remote context, applying principles of hermeneutics to the text. Since the question under consideration stems from these next verses, it is especially important that we now pay special attention to the grammatical context. It would be beneficial for the student to translate these verses in order to gain a deeper understanding of the grammar Jesus used. For verses 18–20, I will provide my translation.
Matthew 18:18
Ἀμὴν λέγω ὑμῖν, ὅσα ἐὰν δήσητε ἐπὶ τῆς γῆς, ἔσται δεδεμένα ἐν τῷ οὐρανῷ· καὶ ὅσα ἐὰν λύσητε ἐπὶ τῆς γῆς, ἔσται λελυμένα ἐν τῷ οὐρανῷ.
“Truly I say to you, whatever things you should bind on the earth, it will have been bound in heaven; and whatever things you should loose on the earth, it will have been loosed in heaven.”
“Bind” and “Loose”
The word translated “bind” comes from δέω (deō), which has a semantic center of “to bind, to tie, to fasten.” In this context, it carries the idea of binding by obligation—requiring something or making it obligatory.
Jesus uses a third-class conditional sentence, which presents a hypothetical situation for consideration. And what hypothetical situation has Jesus just been discussing? He has been discussing the situation described in verses 15–17—a brother who sins against another brother and the steps that are to be taken in an effort to restore him.
An expanded version of the hypothetical might be something like this:
If a situation arises in which the steps of verses 15–17 are followed, and the sinful brother refuses to hear and is consequently disciplined by brethren who are trying to help him repent, then whatever the brethren require on earth…
That is the “if” clause, or protasis, of the conditional sentence—the clause that expresses the condition.
The apodosis is the consequent clause that contains the conclusion:
“…it will have been bound in heaven.”
The words “it will” come from ἔσται (estai), the future form of εἰμί (eimi), “I am,” functioning here with the participle that follows.
That participle is δεδεμένα, the perfect passive participle of δέω. The perfect tense emphasizes an existing state or condition.
The combination of the finite form of εἰμί with the perfect participle forms a periphrastic construction, which places emphasis on the state expressed by the participle.
Therefore, the sense is not that the brethren on earth are creating a new decree in heaven. Rather, the point is that what is bound on earth will already have been bound in heaven.
What Does That Mean?
When brethren follow the steps Jesus has given in verses 15–17 and, in our hypothetical example, the brother refuses to hear and repent, the resulting discipline is in harmony with what God has already authorized.
God’s requirements concerning the restoration and discipline of a sinning brother may have been revealed to mankind through inspired writers, but those requirements did not originate with the brethren on earth. They originate with God.
Heaven has already authorized them.
That is why the discipline of a sinning brother must be carried out according to God’s Word. To change the process, to substitute another process, or to act for some other reason would place the action out of harmony with what heaven has authorized.
The same principle applies to the other half of the statement.
Jesus says:
“…and whatever things you should loose on the earth, it will have been loosed in heaven.”
The word translated “loose” comes from λύω (loo-ōh), which has the semantic center of “to loose, to unbind, to release.” Since it stands in opposition to “bind” in this context, the contextual meaning is to release from an obligation—to permit or not require.
Again, Jesus is dealing with the hypothetical situation described in verses 15–17. If the brother hears, repents, and is restored, then the brethren are to release him from the disciplinary action. They are not to continue requiring something that God has not required. This release is also in harmony with what heaven has already authorized.
In other words, whatever is required or not required on earth, when done in harmony with God’s instructions concerning a brother who has sinned, has already been required or not required in heaven.
God has already sanctioned it.
The key is that the brethren must follow the instructions Jesus has given in verses 15–17, without changing them, without reversing them, and for the right reasons.
Matthew 18:19
Now consider the next verse:
Πάλιν ἀμὴν λέγω ὑμῖν, ὅτι ἐὰν δύο ὑμῶν συμφωνήσωσιν ἐπὶ τῆς γῆς περὶ παντὸς πράγματος οὗ ἐὰν αἰτήσωνται, γενήσεται αὐτοῖς παρὰ τοῦ πατρός μου τοῦ ἐν οὐρανοῖς.
“Again truly I say to you, that if two of you agree upon the earth concerning every matter which they should ask, it shall be done for them from my Father who is in heaven.”
Notice something important. Jesus has not changed the subject. He is continuing the same discussion from verses 15–18 and adding to what He has just said. The same conditional construction appears again.
The word translated “agree” is συμφωνέω (sumphōneō). It means “to sound together, to be in accord, to be in harmony with, to agree.” It is the word from which we get our English word “symphony”—a combination of sounds that are in harmony with one another.
So what is Jesus saying?
The point of verse 19 has not changed from the point of verse 18. If two brethren in Christ agree together concerning what should be done, having followed the steps Jesus has given in verses 15–17, then the Father will sanction what they have done because they are acting in harmony with what Jesus has already said has been authorized in heaven.
The agreement of the two brethren is not what creates God’s approval. Their agreement is significant because they are agreeing with one another in doing what God has already authorized.
Matthew 18:20
Jesus then sums up the thought:
Οὗ γάρ εἰσιν δύο ἢ τρεῖς συνηγμένοι εἰς τὸ ἐμὸν ὄνομα, ἐκεῖ εἰμὶ ἐν μέσῳ αὐτῶν.
“For where two or three are gathered together unto my name, there I am in the midst of them.”
Now notice the connection. Where two or three are gathered together in Jesus’ name—that is, acting by His authority and according to His instructions—Jesus says, “there I am in the midst of them.” It is as though He is personally present, agreeing with what they are doing.
Why? Because they are doing what God’s Word has already authorized.
In this particular context, Jesus is talking about the steps He has just given concerning a brother who has sinned. Two or three brethren have gathered together to deal with that situation according to Jesus’ instructions. When they act in harmony with His will, Jesus is in agreement with what they are doing.
I would add that this principle has application beyond this particular situation. Whenever faithful brethren act in accordance with God’s revealed Word, their authority does not come from the fact that two or three—or even a large number—agree with one another.
Their authority comes from God’s Word. The number of people agreeing does not establish truth. God’s Word establishes truth.
Matthew 18:21–35 — The Need to Forgive
In the final section, Matthew 18:21–35, Jesus emphasizes the need to forgive a brother who sins and repents. He illustrates this principle with a parable and then drives the point home with a practical and personal application in verse 35.
When a sinning brother repents, the offended brother must show compassion and forgive him. If he refuses to forgive, then the offended brother becomes a sinning brother himself.
Just as the master in the parable delivered the wicked servant to punishment because he showed no compassion toward the one who owed him, Jesus concludes:
“So likewise shall my heavenly Father do also unto you, if ye from your hearts forgive not every one his brother their trespasses.” – Matthew 18:35
Once again, the emphasis is on the importance of the child of God and on what must be done when that child has sinned.
What, Then, Does Matthew 18:19–20 Mean?
When we consider the entire context, Jesus is emphasizing the importance of a child of God.
He emphasizes:
- the importance of becoming a child of God;
- the importance of not causing a child of God to sin;
- the importance of bringing a lost child of God back;
- the steps required to accomplish that restoration; and
- the importance of forgiving a penitent brother.
It is within this context—specifically, in doing what it takes to bring an erring brother back into the fold—that Jesus makes the statements in verses 18–20.
If brethren follow the steps Jesus has given, and two or three of them bind or loose according to God’s will, then what they do has already been sanctioned in heaven.
And Jesus says that when they gather together in His name, He also sanctions what you have done as if He was personally there to give His blessing. In that sense, He is in their midst.
Why? Because they are doing what God has already authorized.
Answering the Original Questions
The practice of exegesis—applying principles of hermeneutics to the text in order to draw out its intended meaning—has helped us see what Jesus meant by these verses.
That being the case, let us return to the questions with which we began.
Is Jesus saying that when a small number of Christians come together to pray, worship, or study, He will be there with them?
No. That is not what Matthew 18:19–20 is teaching in its context.
Is Jesus saying that as long as two or three Christians agree on doctrine, He sanctions that teaching as though He were personally present to give His blessing?
Again, no.
The number of people who agree does not determine whether something is true.
Two people can agree and be wrong.
Two hundred people can agree and be wrong.
Two thousand people can agree and be wrong.
What matters is whether what they are doing is in harmony with what God has already authorized.
There is a real danger in twisting what our Lord said in order to make His words conform to our desired meaning.
Would you want your own words to be twisted and misused?
In order to avoid doing that with God’s Word, strive to become knowledgeable about the process of exegesis. Learn to examine the context, the grammar, the words, and the relevant evidence so that you can draw out what God intended to communicate rather than reading your own desired meaning into the text.
TheScriptureStudent.com exists to help you become a better student of the Bible.